The Real Reason You Keep Overreacting to Small Things
This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
When the Small Stuff Feels Way Too Big
You get a short email from your boss: “Let’s talk when you have a minute.” No context, no urgency—but suddenly, your heart is pounding. You scroll through your sent emails, wondering what you did wrong. You’re not just nervous—you’re on high alert.
This is called hypervigilance—a heightened state of sensitivity to potential threats, even when everything’s objectively fine. It’s often rooted in past stress or trauma, and it’s a common driver of emotional reactivity. According to the Cleveland Clinic, hypervigilance keeps your nervous system in constant survival mode, making calm responses harder to access.
Emotional regulation is what helps shift that survival response—so your nervous system doesn’t have to treat every moment like a crisis. Understanding what emotional regulation is (and isn't) is the first step toward shifting that pattern.
It’s Not the Moment—It’s the History Behind It
You’re not overreacting because the moment is that intense. You’re overreacting because your nervous system has been there before. A harmless comment, a neutral tone, a slight delay—your brain isn’t just responding to what’s happening now. It’s responding to what it remembers feeling in similar moments, especially ones where you didn’t feel safe, seen, or in control.
When those memories live in your body unprocessed, they show up as big reactions to small triggers. It’s not that you’re too emotional—it’s that you’re emotionally overloaded. The more you can spot your emotional triggers before they take over, the more space you create to respond instead of react.
2. Your Nervous System Is Reacting, Not Just Your Mind
You may think you’re being irrational—but it’s your nervous system calling the shots. When something small sets you off, you’re likely in a stress response: fight, flight, freeze, fawn, or even flop. These reactions happen in your body long before your brain has time to make sense of the situation.
In The Body Keeps the Score, a fantastic book on trauma, trauma expert Dr. Bessel van der Kolk explains how past emotional wounds—especially those stored in the body—can shape how we respond in everyday life. If your body feels unsafe, your logic doesn’t stand a chance. You might freeze during a routine meeting or over-apologize when no one’s upset with you.
If you’ve ever wondered why other people can stay calm while your chest tightens over something small, this might explain the difference. And if you're curious about the different ways your body responds to stress, check out our guide to Fight, Flight, Freeze, Fawn, and Flop.
3. Overreacting Is Often a Sign You’re Taking It Too Personally
You know the moment: someone makes a neutral comment—“Did you mean to send that version?” or “You seem quiet today”—and suddenly, you feel exposed or criticized. You weren’t planning to take it personally, but it hits something tender.
When you're emotionally flooded, your brain doesn't just hear the words—it fills in the blanks with old fears and insecurities. It assumes judgment, disappointment, or rejection, even when none was intended.
If this feels familiar, you’re not alone. Here are 6 signs you might be taking things too personally—and how to start creating space between what was said and what you felt.
4. You’re Not Overly Sensitive—You’re Emotionally Reactive
Being emotionally reactive doesn’t mean you’re fragile or overly sensitive. Emotional sensitivity is about feeling things deeply. Emotional reactivity is what happens when those feelings drive your behavior before you’ve had a chance to process them.
Reactivity is a learned response—often shaped by stress, past experiences, or environments where you had to be on guard. It’s not a flaw. It’s a nervous system doing what it was trained to do: protect you, fast.
If you’re not sure how often it’s showing up in your day-to-day life, start with these 7 subtle signs of emotional reactivity. Or take the 2-Minute Gut Check Quiz to see if your reactions might be running the show.
5. Check In Before You Spiral Out
That split-second between feeling something and doing something? That’s your window. And it’s bigger than it seems. When your emotions start to rise, even a brief check-in can help interrupt the automatic reaction.
This kind of pause doesn’t require perfection—just awareness. It gives your body a chance to settle and your brain time to process what’s really happening. If you need a simple, repeatable way to do that, these three quick questions are a great place to start. Small check-ins like these can shift everything.
6. Chronic Reactivity Can Affect Mental Health
When emotional reactivity becomes your default setting, it doesn’t just wear on your nerves—it wears on your whole life. Over time, constant overreactions can leave you feeling drained, disconnected, and unsure of yourself.
It’s not just stressful—it’s depleting. Your energy takes a hit. Relationships get strained. And your self-esteem can quietly erode under the weight of second-guessing everything you feel. According to the National Institute of Mental Health, chronic stress affects nearly every system in the body—including mood, focus, and emotional resilience.
If you're noticing the toll, here are 6 ways reactivity impacts your mental health—and what to do instead to restore your capacity to feel safe in your own skin.
7. Tools That Help You Respond Instead of React
You don’t need to white-knuckle your way through every emotional spiral. The right tools can help create just enough space between the trigger and your reaction—so you can respond with intention instead of instinct.
Breathwork, grounding exercises, and emotional labeling are a few practices that teach your body how to come back to center. But the key isn’t using them once—it’s building a rhythm of regulation that your nervous system can rely on.
Start with these emotional regulation tools that actually work, or explore Build Your Own Calm Box to begin building your own daily calm routine. It doesn’t have to be perfect. Just practiced.
It’s Not Overreacting—It’s Unprocessed Protection
You’re not broken, dramatic, or “too much.” Your reactions make sense when you consider what they’re built on—years of stress, subtle hurts, survival strategies, and moments when your needs went unmet.
You can’t always control the trigger. But you can learn to slow the spin, respond with more clarity, and give your nervous system the safety it’s been looking for. Here are 7 benefits of learning to respond instead of react—because even small shifts can lead to big relief.
If you're ready to go deeper, From Reacting to Responding: A 5-Day Emotional Reset is a guided experience designed to help you practice these shifts day by day.
Not sure where to begin? Take the 2-Minute React vs Response Quiz to start noticing your own patterns. Awareness is the first move toward balance.